Hey. So this will be a good test run for my first post on this forum. I'm mostly curious about who will respond, if anyone. If moderators are the ones responding, then it seems counter productive to the direction to bring disagreements here. I mean, what would be the point of bringing it here if they already wont discuss it on the server itself. Anyway, we'll see. I have an issue with rule 8. Now it may end up being as simple as: we said it, so you'll deal with it or you'll leave. If so, I'll (quite disappointingly) let it go quicker than the world got sick of the song in Frozen. The issue I have is that while Rule 8 seems good as a concept, I believe that at times it is abused. In this case, for example, we had a player on red server who really annoyed the community with his style of play: it was mostly griefing and tp-killing, or at least it seemed that way. His name was Oofla, or Oolfa. I never remembered how it was spelled. For the record, I was taken advantage of by this person really early on during my time on the server. I believed then, as I do now, that it was cheating. I don't wish to get into why unless you're curious because it is irrelevant to this issue. What is relevant is that I, despite how I felt about this (extremely pissed), often encouraged new players via /msg to be even more careful with tp requests than staff and helpers were doing. I'd often discuss what happened with people, being an ear if they needed someone to complain to or talking through methods to be more careful in the future. I always dissagreed with staff who said, "just don't accept" as I knew that there were ways to enjoy the multiplayer server we were on. All that was required was wisdom. So I would happily discuss this wisdom with other players. I would also discourage people to seek revenge or blow up chat with anger. There are lessons that can be learned from the situation, but anger isn't helpful. Herein lies the issue I take against Rule 8, and the Moderators ending such discussion. Oolfa has been banned (for reasons unknown to me or anyone, despite him having taken advantage of most of us. ~I don't agree that silencing discussion on why he was banned is beneficial. For one, it is cathartic for those taken advantage of: justice is often more about the victims and potential victims than it is about the accused.~ The second issue I take with silencing discussion of Oofla, is that if he is banned, then "angry chat" will die out as it becomes memory and people move on. However, there is positive outcomes to this discussion: ~Firstly, discussion griefing as well as how to respond to it will always be helpful.~ Newbies who may or may not stay on this server can learn a thing or two and having a community who cares enough to train them up against grief, tp-killing, and etc, is much more likely to remain. ~Secondly, having shared experience bonds the members of the server and makes everyone feel more at home.~ Silencing such discussion only makes players feel out of place, like they can't discuss some harmless subject and it is harmless; this bring me to my third point. Finally, Discussion of Oofla (while shown above to be helpful in a few ways) is harmless. There is no way that such discussion can be harmful. If anyone has broken rules routinely, and have been banned, then it only serves your server to hold them up as an example. Hush, hushing it away doesn't do you any good. As I've pointed out above, anger will die out as time moves on and people move on. All that's left is talking about griefing methods and protecting one's self from them. As it stands, you only damage your server integrity wasting Rule 8 on something like Oofla, when such a rule is meant to shut down aggressive/offensive conversation. Damaging your server integrity will affect how player feel about it, despite it being ever so subtle. I, for example, felt this was so much an issue of abuse of power that I came here to post how I "Disagree with Staff". As the only person who ever reached out and extended my friendship to such an aggravating person who , I hope you'll consider my argument and amend the behavior of your Moderators.