Hey Guys! Some of you may not know me, but I am DoggoDoge123. I play on blue server and 1v1 a lot. Yesterday, on blue server, @Bavtato voted and won a spawner. Me, knowing I am working to open my own town, tried to buy the mob spawner. Not after long, Courquake decided she also wanted to buy a spawner. Knowing my liking for PvP, I decided to do a duel for the spawner. Courquake happily said yes to the duel. A few minutes later, Bavtato teleported Cour and I to Elysium's PvP arena. I arrived there, hyped us as I could be(considering that I havent had a "real" rare pvp battle in a while") and ready for pvp. Bavtato shut us both down for using rares. Although I do not have screenshots Bavtato, Courquake, and my messages, What happened was Bavtato did not want us using "OP" items for this pvp battle. So, I agreed and threw my Melon of truth and Dreamthistle into me ./ec. After the pvp battle, I think i put both the melon and Dreamthistle back on(not sure), and logged out for the night. This afternoon, I logged back into to realize that my Melon of Truth is gone. Although I am not exactly upset at Bavtato, I am upset by Applecraft's "replacement rare" policy. What is you guys feelings about this? What do you think would be the right thing to do?